How to Fix Common Magnetic Box Problems (Hard to Open + Weak Magnets)
A women’s bridal boutique owner, Clara, started using magnetic boxes for her $800 wedding dresses last year. The feedback was immediate—and frustrating. “The boxes look stunning, but brides struggle to open them without ruining their manicures,” she says. Worse, a few boxes popped open during shipping, leaving dresses slightly crumpled. For clothing brands, magnetic boxes that are too hard to open or have weak magnets don’t just annoy customers—they undermine the luxury feel you’re paying for.
Whether you’re packaging suits, silk dresses, or using magnetic boxes for gifts (like holiday sweater sets), these issues are fixable. Below’s how to diagnose and solve the two most common problems, with real examples from clothing brands.
Problem: Magnetic Boxes Are Too Hard to Open
A box that requires brute force to open ruins the unboxing experience—especially for customers in delicate clothing (think brides in lace gloves or clients trying to open boxes in your store).
Why It Happens:
-Magnets are too strong: Suppliers often use heavy-duty magnets for “security,” but they’re overkill for clothing boxes. A men’s suit brand found their boxes used 20mm thick magnets—way stronger than needed for a 2lb suit.
-Lid alignment is off: If the lid sits unevenly, the magnets clamp down too tightly on one side, making it hard to pry open. A linen shirt brand noticed their boxes’ lids were 1mm off-center—enough to create a “stuck” feel.
Quick Fixes (No Need to Rebuy Boxes):
Add a small “lip”: Stick a thin piece of matching cardstock (1cm wide) to the inside edge of the lid with eco-friendly glue. This creates a tiny tab to grip, making it easier to pull open. Clara tried this for her bridal boxes—brides (and their manicures) immediately noticed the difference.
Loosen magnets slightly: For boxes with exposed magnet edges (common in unlined designs), gently pry the magnet up 1-2mm with a flathead screwdriver (be careful not to tear the box). This reduces contact strength. A knitwear brand used this trick—boxes now open smoothly but still stay shut during shipping.
How to Avoid It in Future Orders:
-Specify “medium-strength magnets” (10-15mm thick) when ordering. Most clothing (suits, dresses, shirts) doesn’t need heavy-duty versions.
-Ask suppliers to add a 3mm “gap” between lid and base when closed—just enough to slide a finger in. A custom shirt brand now includes this in their order notes, eliminating stuck lids entirely.
Problem: Weak Magnets (Boxes Pop Open)
A magnetic box that won’t stay closed is worse than a regular box—it makes your packaging look cheap and risks damaging clothing (wrinkles, snags) during shipping.
Why It Happens:
– Magnets are undersized: Suppliers sometimes skimp on magnet size to cut costs. A silk scarf brand found their boxes used 5mm magnets—too weak to hold the lid shut if the box is jostled.
– damage: Humidity (common in warehouses) can weaken magnet strength over time. A swimwear brand stored boxes in a damp basement—30% of them lost magnet power within 3 months.
– Fabric interference: Thick liners (like felt or velvet) can block magnetic force if they’re too close to the magnet. A wool coat brand used 8mm felt liners over their magnets—weakening the pull.
Quick Fixes (Salvage Existing Boxes):
– Add adhesive magnet strips: Buy 10mm self-adhesive magnets (eBay or craft stores) and stick them directly over the existing magnets (inside the lid and base). Ensure they align perfectly. A suit brand fixed 200 boxes this way—costing $0.30/box but saving them from reordering.
– Reposition liners: If thick liners are the issue, trim a 1cm square around the magnet area (so the liner doesn’t sit between magnets). A velvet blazer brand did this—magnet strength instantly improved.
How to Avoid It in Future Orders:
– Order boxes with “encased magnets” (sealed in plastic) to resist moisture. A raincoat brand switched to these—no more humidity-related weakening.
– For lined boxes, specify “magnet recesses” (suppliers carve a small indent for magnets, so liners lie flat over them without blocking force). A luxury sweater brand now requires this—their velvet-lined boxes stay shut reliably.
Bonus: Fixes for Magnetic Boxes for Gifts
When using magnetic boxes for gifts (like holiday shirt sets or anniversary silk scarves), presentation matters even more—here’s how to solve unique gift-specific issues:
– “Too tight” for tissue paper: If adding tissue makes the lid hard to close (weakening magnets over time), ask for 0.5cm extra height. A gift set brand did this—tissue fits easily, and magnets stay strong.
– Lid pops open when wrapped: Wrapping paper can push against the lid, causing weak magnets to fail. Add a small sticker (matching your brand) over the lid edge to hold it shut during gifting—customers can remove it easily.
Real Example: A Suit Brand’s Fix Journey
Marc owns a small men’s suit brand that struggled with both issues:
– First, boxes were too hard to open—customers complained about “fighting with the lid.”
– He switched suppliers, but the new boxes had weak magnets—15% popped open during shipping.
His solution:
– For hard-to-open boxes: Added 1cm cardstock lips to 500 boxes ($150 total).
– For weak magnets: Ordered 10mm adhesive strips and reenforced 300 boxes ($90 total).
– For future orders: Specified medium-strength (12mm) magnets with 3mm gaps and recessed liners.
Result: Complaints dropped to zero, and customers now mention the “smooth opening” in reviews.
Wrapping Up
Magnetic boxes enhance your clothing brand’s luxury feel—when they work properly. Too-hard-to-open lids or weak magnets aren’t deal-breakers—they’re fixable with simple tweaks.
Clara, the bridal boutique owner, sums it up: “We spent months perfecting our dress designs—why let a box ruin that? A small lip on the lid made all the difference.”
Whether you’re packaging daily wear or using magnetic boxes for gifts, the key is to test boxes before full orders, specify magnet strength in your requests, and don’t hesitate to make small adjustments. Your customers (and their unboxing experiences) will thank you.
Need Expert Guidance?
ANG specializes in custom packaging for global fashion brands. Contact us for a free consultation Design and Samples.
English